Imagine this: Two candidates apply for an insurance sales position. Both have great resumes, industry experience, and confident personalities. You hire them both. Fast forward six months—one is outperforming the entire team, closing deals effortlessly, while the other struggles to meet even half of their sales targets.
What made the difference?
It wasn’t just experience. It wasn’t just personality. It was sales aptitude. And this is exactly why an insurance sales test is critical for making better hiring decisions.
In this guide, we’ll explore:
✅ What an insurance sales test is and why it matters
✅ The essential traits of top-performing insurance sales agents
✅ How to implement an insurance sales test in your hiring process
✅ Real-world insights from my 20+ years of experience in hiring sales professionals
What Is an Insurance Sales Test?
An insurance sales test is a pre-employment assessment designed to measure a candidate’s suitability for selling insurance products. It evaluates:
🔹 Persuasion Skills – Can they influence potential clients?
🔹 Resilience & Persistence – Do they handle rejection well?
🔹 Emotional Intelligence – Can they build trust quickly?
🔹 Product Knowledge Aptitude – Can they grasp complex insurance policies?
🔹 Competitiveness & Drive – Do they have a hunger for success?
Unlike generic sales assessment tests (comprehensive sales assessment guide here), this test is industry-specific, ensuring candidates have the mindset and skills required for the unique challenges of selling insurance.
The DNA of a Successful Insurance Sales Agent
Hiring an insurance sales agent is different from hiring a general salesperson. Why? Because insurance is not an impulse purchase. Selling it requires trust-building, persistence, and a consultative approach.
After two decades of working with companies to refine their hiring strategies, here’s what I’ve learned about top-performing insurance sales agents:
✅ They Sell Solutions, Not Products
They don’t just pitch policies; they solve problems. Whether it’s life insurance or business liability coverage, they focus on how the policy protects the customer’s future.
✅ They Handle Rejection Like a Pro
Rejection is a daily reality in insurance sales. The best agents don’t take “no” personally. They see it as an opportunity to learn and refine their pitch.
✅ They’re Masters of the Follow-Up
A successful insurance sale rarely happens in the first conversation. The best agents nurture leads over time, using strategic follow-ups to close deals.
✅ They Are Trust Builders
Insurance isn’t about selling a product—it’s about selling peace of mind. High-performing agents establish trust quickly and maintain long-term client relationships.
How an Insurance Sales Test Helps You Hire Top Performers
Traditional hiring methods—resumes, interviews, and references—only tell part of the story. An insurance sales test goes deeper, giving you data-driven insights into a candidate’s actual selling potential.
📌 Screen Out the Wrong Hires Early
Many candidates can talk the talk but fail when it’s time to sell. The test filters out those who lack the core skills needed for success.
📌 Reduce Turnover & Improve Performance
Hiring the wrong salespeople is expensive. Replacing a poor hire can cost up to $100,000 when you factor in lost sales and training. A well-implemented insurance sales test helps you build a stronger, more stable sales team.
📌 Make Data-Driven Hiring Decisions
Why rely on gut feeling when you can use science? A test provides measurable insights into a candidate’s sales aptitude, giving you confidence in your hiring decisions.
How to Implement an Insurance Sales Test in Your Hiring Process
Want to integrate an insurance sales test into your recruitment process? Here’s a step-by-step guide:
1️⃣ Define Your Ideal Sales Profile
Use data from your top-performing agents to identify key traits and skills you need.
2️⃣ Incorporate the Test Early in the Process
Use it before the first interview to screen out weak candidates early.
3️⃣ Pair It with Behavioral Interviews
Combine test results with targeted interview questions to validate a candidate’s potential.
4️⃣ Compare Scores with Performance Metrics
If possible, compare test results with your team’s sales data over time. This will help you refine your hiring criteria.
Choosing the Right Insurance Sales Test for Your Business
Not all sales assessments are created equal. The best tests measure a combination of cognitive ability, personality, and sales skills. We offer several specialized tests tailored to insurance sales, including:
📌 Sales Predictor Profile – Identifies natural sales talent
📌 Sales Ability Test – Measures core selling skills
📌 Sales People Logic Test – Assesses problem-solving ability in sales scenarios
📌 Sales Personality Test – Evaluates sales-specific personality traits
Check out our pricing page for details on test options.
Final Thoughts: Are You Ready to Hire Better Sales Agents?
Insurance sales is a tough industry, but hiring the right people doesn’t have to be. By using an insurance sales test, you can:
✅ Identify top performers before you hire them
✅ Reduce turnover and increase sales
✅ Make hiring decisions based on data, not just intuition
Want to see how an insurance sales test can work for your company?
📞 Schedule a Demo with our assessment experts today.
We’ll walk you through the process, show you real-world case studies, and help you find the best way to assess your candidates.
👉 Don’t gamble with your sales team. Make data-driven hiring decisions.
Content
