The Complete Guide to Personality Assessments in Hiring

·  6 minutes read

A decade ago, I sat across from a candidate who seemed perfect on paper. He had the experience, the credentials, and he aced every interview question. Yet, within three months, he was gone—unable to adapt to the company culture and struggling to collaborate with the team.

That experience made one thing painfully clear: resumes and interviews don’t tell the full story.

Hiring managers everywhere face the same challenge. How do you truly know whether a candidate will thrive in your work environment? How do you predict whether someone will be a strong leader, a great collaborator, or a motivated salesperson?

The answer lies in personality assessments—powerful tools that go beyond skills and experience to measure behavior, work style, and long-term potential.

What Is a Personality Assessment?

A personality assessment is a scientifically validated test that evaluates an individual’s behavioral traits, work habits, and interpersonal style.

Unlike skill-based tests that measure what a candidate knows, personality tests reveal how they think, act, and interact.

Think of it as a blueprint of how a person naturally operates in a work setting.

Why Are Personality Assessments Crucial in Hiring?

Two sales candidates symbolizing high vs low confidence

Traditional hiring methods rely heavily on resumes and interviews, which can be subjective and misleading.

Consider this:

📌 A Harvard Business Review study found that 80% of employee turnover is due to poor hiring decisions, not lack of skill.
📌 Research from the American Psychological Association shows that personality traits predict job performance as effectively as cognitive ability tests.
📌 Companies using personality assessments see a 25% reduction in turnover rates.

In other words, hiring based on personality fit isn’t just smart—it’s essential.

🔹 Want to hire smarter? Explore our Personality and Behavioral Assessments.

How Personality Tests Improve Hiring Decisions

When used correctly, personality assessments help:

Improve Hiring Accuracy – Identify candidates who align with job demands and company culture.
Reduce Employee Turnover – Ensure candidates will enjoy and excel in their roles.
Build Stronger Teams – Balance different work styles for better collaboration.
Enhance Productivity – Place employees in roles that match their natural strengths.

Imagine hiring a sales rep who hates cold calling, a customer service agent who struggles with patience, or a leader who can’t communicate effectively.

Without personality assessments, you’re guessing whether a candidate will be a good fit. With them, you’re making data-driven decisions.

🔹 Looking for a quick evaluation? Try our Short Personality Test.

Different Types of Personality Assessments for Hiring

Personality plays a crucial role in job performance, workplace dynamics, and leadership effectiveness. But not all personality assessments are created equal—some are better suited for leadership selection, while others are ideal for sales roles or team compatibility. The right test depends on your hiring goals and the traits that are most important for the role.

Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of the best personality assessments for hiring, their purpose, and how they can optimize your talent selection strategy.

1. The Big Five Personality Test – Predicting Workplace Behavior

One of the most scientifically validated models, the Big Five Personality Test assesses individuals based on five core traits that strongly correlate with workplace behavior:

Openness – Measures creativity, adaptability, and curiosity. High scorers excel in innovation and problem-solving, making them ideal for roles requiring strategic thinking.
Conscientiousness – Determines self-discipline, reliability, and organization. This is the strongest predictor of job performance across all roles.
Extraversion – Evaluates sociability, assertiveness, and enthusiasm. Best suited for sales, marketing, and leadership positions.
Agreeableness – Measures teamwork, empathy, and cooperation. High scorers thrive in customer service, HR, and collaborative work environments.
Neuroticism (Emotional Stability) – Assesses resilience, stress tolerance, and emotional control. Low scorers (high emotional stability) perform well in high-pressure roles like leadership and crisis management.

📌 Best for: Identifying leadership potential, assessing team compatibility, and predicting long-term job performance.
🔹 Explore the Big Five Personality Test here.

2. The DISC Personality Test – Understanding Communication Styles

Effective communication is essential for workplace collaboration, and the DISC Personality Test is designed to measure how individuals interact with others. The model categorizes people into four primary behavioral styles:

D – Dominance – Bold, assertive, and results-driven; thrives in leadership and competitive sales roles.
I – Influence – Charismatic, persuasive, and social; excels in customer-facing and networking-driven positions.
S – Steadiness – Loyal, dependable, and patient; ideal for team-based roles and client relationship management.
C – Conscientiousness – Detail-oriented, analytical, and systematic; well-suited for data-heavy, technical, or compliance-driven roles.

📌 Best for: Sales roles, leadership development, and workplace communication improvement.
🔹 Learn more in our DISC Personality Guide here.

3. Leadership Personality Assessments – Identifying Future Leaders

Leadership is more than just experience—it’s about decision-making, emotional intelligence, and resilience. A Leadership Personality Assessment helps companies identify individuals with the right traits to excel in management roles, including:

Decision-Making Ability – Can they think strategically and handle high-pressure situations?
Conflict Resolution Skills – How effectively do they manage workplace disputes?
Emotional Intelligence – Do they have the self-awareness and empathy needed for leadership?
Risk-Taking Behavior – Are they cautious decision-makers or bold innovators?

📌 Best for: Identifying high-potential leaders, succession planning, and ensuring cultural fit in management roles.
🔹 Explore our Leadership Personality Assessment here.

4. Sales Personality Tests – Identifying High-Performing Salespeople

Sales is one of the toughest professions, and hiring the wrong salespeople can cost businesses thousands in lost revenue. The Sales Personality Test helps companies identify top-performing sales candidates by evaluating:

Competitiveness – Do they thrive in a high-energy, goal-driven environment?
Persuasiveness – Can they build trust and influence buying decisions?
Resilience – How well do they handle rejection and overcome objections?
Rapport-Building Ability – Are they skilled in fostering long-term customer relationships?

📌 Best for: Sales hiring, reducing turnover, and improving quota attainment.
🔹 Assess your next sales hire with our Sales Personality Test here.

5. Workplace Personality Assessments – Enhancing Team Dynamics

A strong team is built on trust, collaboration, and complementary skills. A Workplace Personality Assessment ensures team cohesion by measuring:

Work Style Compatibility – Do employees prefer structure or flexibility?
Collaboration vs. Independence – Are they team players or solo contributors?
Problem-Solving Approach – How do they handle workplace challenges?

📌 Best for: Optimizing team structure, improving employee engagement, and building high-performing departments.
🔹 Explore our workplace personality assessment here.

6. Insights Personality Assessment – Uncovering Work Motivations

Based on Jungian psychology, the Insights Personality Assessment goes beyond behavior to analyze how individuals think, process information, and make decisions. 

It categorizes employees into color-coded personality types that indicate their communication styles, strengths, and challenges in the workplace.

📌 Best for: Leadership development, improving workplace culture, and enhancing team collaboration.
🔹 Learn more about the Insights Personality Assessment here.

7. AI-Powered Personality Assessments – The Future of Hiring

With advances in artificial intelligence, AI-driven personality assessments now provide deeper insights than ever before. These tools use machine learning to analyze behavioral patterns, assess cognitive abilities, and predict real-world job performance with higher accuracy than traditional assessments.

📌 Best for: Companies looking for data-driven hiring strategies and automated, bias-free assessments.
🔹 Explore AI-powered personality assessments here.

Choosing the Right Personality Assessment for Your Business

Two colleagues collaborating on a project

Not sure which test is right for your hiring needs? Here’s a quick guide:

For leadership hiring → Big Five, Leadership Personality Assessments
For sales roles → Sales Personality Test, DISC Personality Test
For team-building → Workplace Personality Test, Insights Personality Assessment
For data-driven hiring → AI-Powered Personality Assessments

Want to see these assessments in action? Our hiring experts can help you implement the right test for your business.

🔹 Schedule a Demo Today to find the perfect personality assessment for your team.

How to Use Personality Assessments in Your Hiring Process

Step 1: Define Key Traits for Each Role

  • Is the job fast-paced or methodical?
  • Does it require independence or collaboration?
  • Should the candidate be more analytical or creative?

Step 2: Use Personality Tests Early in the Hiring Process

  • Assess candidates before final interviews to focus on the right fit.
  • Identify strengths and weaknesses before making an offer.

Step 3: Combine Assessments with Other Hiring Methods

  • Use structured interviews to verify test results.
  • Compare personality insights with skills tests and behavioral questions.

🔹 Not sure where to start? Schedule a Demo to see how personality assessments can improve your hiring process.

Common Myths About Personality Tests

🔸 “They’re not reliable.”
Truth: When validated, they are backed by decades of research.

🔸 “They can replace interviews.”
Truth: They should complement, not replace, interviews.

🔸 “They limit diversity.”
Truth: They help remove bias and ensure fair hiring.

Final Thoughts: Why Every Business Should Use Personality Assessments

The right hire is more than a resume. Personality assessments help you:
✔ Find candidates who fit your culture.
✔ Build high-performing teams.
✔ Reduce costly hiring mistakes.

Why take chances when you can hire with confidence?🔗 Schedule a Demo to see how personality assessments can transform your hiring strategy.

Content

    Fletcher Wimbush  ·  CEO at Discovered.AI
    Fletcher Wimbush · CEO at Discovered.AI
    Book a Demo of Our Assessments Today!